Shabbat shalom! And G’mar tov (Good seal)! The latter greeting is based on the belief that a person’s fate for the coming year is written on Rosh Hashanah and sealed on Yom Kippur. “G’mar tov” expresses the wish that the person be inscribed and sealed in the Book of Life for a good year.
It has not been a good year for Jews. We have lived through a pogrom, a year of death and devestating destruction, and a level of anti-semitism not seen in the post-holocaust period. Period.
Israel is currently fighting a war on at least 5 fronts, against an enemy that wants to commit a real genocide against our people. And Israel is fighting this war with an incompetent government that lacks trust and that relies on the votes of ultra-Orthodox, who by the way, do not serve in the armies and demand a draft exemption. And the fact that the country is navigating what is probably the darkest moment in its history with the least competent government is rather extraordinary. And despite all that, there is a feeling that a page has turned, and the Israeli lion has awoken and is kicking ass and taking out terrorists and doing the world a giant favor by reducing the ability for the jihadists to continue killing innocent people in the name of Allah. And while Jews around the world celebrate what is considered by many the holiest of holidays, we wait for Israel’s response to the latest missile barrage from Iran. It’s time to chop the head off the evil octopus.
The toll on the Israeli people has been heavy. This tiny country, the size of New Jersey with a population of 10 million, is still suffering from the trauma of October 7, the worst and most horrific butchering of innocent people in my lifetime. And the hostages, over 100 that are still suffering in the dark dungeons of Hamas hell tunnels, continue to weigh heavily on any decent human’s spirit, but especially on the very soul of Israel and Israelis. And the country remains divided on not only what to do about them, but how to honor them.
That was symbolized this last week by two competing October 7 ceremonies: an unofficial ceremony that was put together by the families of hostages, most notably by Jonathan Shamriz, a very impressive young Israeli, whose brother Alon was taken hostage on October 7, and then sadly, was one of the three hostages killed mistakenly by the IDF. That ceremony was held in Tel Aviv and was supposed to be attended by about 40,000 people, but tickets ran out within a matter of hours and then was reduced to a much smaller group due to the threat of rocket attacks. That unofficial ceremony was followed by an official state ceremony put together by the Netanyahu government and pre-recorded, in part because they were worried that if it was filmed live, people would protest and/or disrupt the ceremony.
Shamriz, wearing a white t-shirt printed with the name of his devastated kibbutz, Kfar Aza, and a yellow ribbon, recalled being in the shelter with his family, holding the door closed against terrorists with a kitchen knife in his hand, receiving updates on his phone about the massacre taking place.

“It was a day without an army, without a state — a day where all we had was ourselves, the citizens. This is what abandonment looks like,” says Shamriz. “Instead of standing here as multitudes of the people of Israel, united, we stand here waiting for the next siren. Instead of a state inquiry commission being established to investigate this colossal failure, we are asking the questions ourselves without getting any answers.” “There is no personal example, no vision, no leadership, no accountability,” he says, to applause from the audience.
Ouch.
But Shamriz ends on a positive note, and is a reminder of the redemptive spirit and resilience of this amazing people. Shamriz says he believes a new generation is rising out of the ruins and destruction, a generation that believes in the Israeli spirit, that will rebuild and create a better, more moral country. And it’s the generation that we’re seeing now fighting in Gaza and in Lebanon, an incredible young generation. And while his speech may have been a dark statement on Israeli leadership, it ended with a very positive message, and a statement of pure Zionism.
“Alon, you hero, thank you for showing us the path. Thank you for setting the standards. We will not desist until we have fixed things. We will not rest until we have rebuilt. We are the generation that will emerge from the ruins, the holocaust, the inferno, and will realize the new Zionist vision. And when that happens, I will know that Alon’s path has become reality. Rise! Am Yisrael Chai! The people of Israel live.”
Amazing.
While there are positive developments on the war front in Israel, things have gotten worse here in the diaspora, particularly here in the good ole US of A. For example, at Columbia University, Jewish students tried to organize a quiet ceremony to honor the hostages and Jews slaughtered on October 7th. And it was effectively overrun by a counter protest, by mask wearing, keffiyeh wearing, Hamas and Hezbollah flag waving protesters, who were chanting the language of Hamas, “from the river to the sea”, “bomb Tel Aviv”, “globalize the Intifada”, and other hateful horse shit. These are the same morons that probably tore down posters of hostages. And this kind of nonsense was happening all over the country, not to mention the new report from the ADL that anti-semitic attacks went up by over 200% in a single year. Makes me want to puke.
A silver lining in all this hatred is that Jews are returning to shul, to their synagogues, and to other Jewish communities in record numbers. Probably out of fear and safety, but nevertheless, a silver lining I will take no matter the reason. Even my wife and I attended our synagogue’s Yom Kippur service last night via Zoom, although I confess, and will now atone for, falling asleep during the service.
Rather than my usual listing of mostly bad news for the Jews across the globe, I thought I would end this post on a more positive note. While some kind of peaceful solution in Israel seems generations away from reality, and while Israelis try to deal with the existential threat imposed upon them by Iran and its proxies, there needs to be some kind of hope for a peaceful way forward, for both Israelis and Palestinians that want peace. After all, the national anthem for Israel, “Hatikvah”, is literally the word “hope”. And so in that perhaps naive context, I present to JNR readers this song of hope, organized by a singing group called Koolulam, and led by Matisyahu, a well known American reggae singer, rapper, beatboxer, and musician. On February 14, 2018, Koolulam invited 3,000 people who had never met before to sing in Haifa, “One Day” in three languages, (Hebrew, Arabic and English), in celebration of co-existence, and in collaboration with Beit HaGefen, the Haifa Municipality, and the Port of Haifa. It took just under one hour for the 3,000 to learn all the parts, and here is the result.
These are the voices and the faces of hope.
One day, hopefully soon, our hostages will come back alive. One day, there will be peace in the middle east. Until then, be careful out there.
Brad out.











